While many are quick to criticize Canada's "poor showing" at the Olympics, few are willing to define what "success" looks like. The criticism usually begins with something that compares us with the United States and ends with the usual call for throwing more taxpayer dollars at the "issue".
For obvious reasons we can't compare our Olympic medal total with the United States. For starters, their population of 300 million people is almost ten times that our nation's. Not to mention the fact that the United States has a much longer summer for training.
What would be appropriate when considering success for our nation, is Canada's medal haul on a per basis with other countries. Below is a per capita medal earnings comparison between Canada and the top ten medal earning nations.
1) Australia 1:572,222
2) United Kingdom 1:1,691,666
3) South Korea 1:2,050,000
4) France 1:2,133,333
5) CANADA 1:2,553,846
6) Italy 1:2905000
7) Germany 1:2,942,857
8) Russia 1:3,126,666
9) United States 1:3,845,569
10) Japan 1:5,534,782
11) China 1:16,835,443
Suddenly, Canada's one medal for every 2,553,846 people is looking pretty respectable. As you can see, when compared with the top ten medal earning nations, Canada places fifth. Those that are keen on comparing us with the United States can take solace in the fact that on a per capita basis, their nation currently ranks 9th.
Further, as Kevin pointed out, our current total of 13 medals has already passsed the 2004 total of 12. Perhaps it's time for the critics to stop bashing our nation's "poor showing" and to start by cheering our men and women on for their great showing.
Sources:
Population totals - CIA World Fact Book - https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/
Medal standings (as of Wednesday morning) - Official 2008 Olympic Web Site - http://results.beijing2008.cn/WRM/ENG/INF/GL/95A/GL0000000.shtml
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
Olympic Success?
Posted by
colinandrewcraig
at
8:11 AM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Your comment on "longer summer for training" for Canadian atheletes is for the most part incorect.
Very few summer olympic athletes train in Canada. Many Canadian athletes either go to college in the US and therefore train during their academic year with the benefit of better weather, yet others train full time in the US using various US facilities (usually training with other athletes from around the world that they will compete against.)
A further comparison would be to look at funding per athlete in each sport compared to peers in that sport as well as the benefits and bonuses received if they attain a medal. The allure of a significant payday upon winning a gold medal must have even the slightest influence when deciding to continue one's sacrifices on the journey to olympic success.
Post a Comment