CTF in the News

Loading...

Wednesday, November 23, 2005

The Saskatchewan government rigged the poll

I just returned from the Saskatchewan legislature where I was talking to media about the rigged poll at the province's web site advocating for a sweeter equalization deal (check previous post and SDA for background).

At first a NDP staffer told me the poll was "hacked." I initially considered this a plausible explanation but the longer I thought about it the more I realized that if some nefarious individual or organization was able to hack the government web site for such a ridiculous purpose we have a damn serious government security problem on our hands.

Then the Premier was scrummed by reporters and was immediately asked about Small Dead Animals and raise-a-flag-gate. He made some jokes about listening to "small dead people" and asked why anyone would pay any mind to an organization with such a name or read blogs "or whatever you call them."

He then went on to say that raiseaflag.ca was indeed tampered with. He says that all of a sudden a thousand mischief makers logged on to the site and voted no. They responded to this security breech by basically restoring the setting on the poll to what is was before the mischief-makers flocked to the site.

In other words, they rigged the poll.

I'm not going to jump into hyperbolic North Korea-style propaganda metaphors, but this has to be the most ridiculous move a government could make. Those thousand mischief makers who voted "no" were actual people. Perhaps they didn't appreciate the fact the government is spending tax dollars on a publicity campaign aimed at extracting more tax dollars from Ontario and Alberta. Perhaps some of those individuals see the equalization program as a provincial welfare trap that rewards basket-case economies and punishes growing economies. Perhaps this was their way of protesting against this manipulative campaign.

The Premier said he didn't have any faith in "unscientific online polls" but you can be sure that he would not hesitate to use the fictitious 90 per cent support level if challenged on the merits of the campaign. If, Premier Calvert, you have no faith in unscientific online polls you should stop using them as manipulative propaganda tools.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

David:

This is DISGUSTING...

I thought we were bad in Ontario voting for the Liberals.

At least they don't trample democracy as overtly....

-W. Teevens

Josef said...

The only reason this Yank voted in that poll was to see if it was tampered with... at Kate of SDA's request.

David MacLean said...

Doesn't matter, Kate says it was rigged before she got there.

Chad Moats said...

Obviously someone had a brainfart at the Leg. What would have been a total non-story, the poll results, is now a big brother issue, poll tampering. Though a stupid thing for an employee to do, it is not an infraction of the Charter nor is it the socialist monster rearing it's head.
Your right we shouldn't be begging for money when we are a have province for the first time ever. We be shouting from the roofs but at the same time canadian federalism is uneven with special accords and side deals for extra funding.This needs to be corrected by applying the same equation for Alberta as Newfoundland thus altering the formula to include, or not ,energy revenue in the formula for every province and territory.

Anonymous said...

I voted on this stupid poll early Saturday morning when it came out (I voted no, BTW) and the results were something like 60% opposed to "fairness" (I also posted the result ont his site). I went back to check it a few hours later, and it was in the highly in favour. Of course, having a poor result would have been embarassing for Calvert: but you would think that censorship is more embarassing?

PS

archie said...

Who's against getting a better deal for our province? You young people on this blog must have a lot of spare time on their hands. Who the hell has time to hijack a govrnment survey that in this case was a good effort. It's just a survey. If you think we should fly our flag at half mast or have our premier denounce Canada...Baloney.Newfoundland doen't have a lot going for it but high taxes,high unemployment and low wages. They need something like this more than we do. They are a broke province we're not and because we're now a "have" province it's are harder sell. We'll get a deal.I know the premier and the government will try.

CTF You Tube Channel

Canadian Taxpayers Federation's Fan Box